Criminals use guns because handguns are so readily available. Following the discussion, divide the class into several groups, each one taking up one of the categories.
New York City and Washington, D. Citizens must be willing to instigate and evaluate good laws, not simply to obey or ignore them.
Issues of Public Policy.
The scope of teaching and learning opportunities offered by the debate is suggested in Table 1. The following overview of the policy debate on gun violence, and the accompanying classroom strategy, suggest an alternative model for public policy formulation.
It is not necessary that issues be violence-related in order to teach the fundamental concepts of social justice, public responsibility, tolerance, and equity. Nor is it simply about liking or not liking control. Gun control advocates argue from a public health standpoint, noting that while guns may not cause violence, they do cause violence to be far more lethal.
Public policy analysis gun control challenge is to combine the attraction and inherent interest of the issue with a genuine desire to seek information, solutions, and above all, effective public policy.
Pacific Institute for Public Policy Research, For example, while decreasing adult homicide rates in urban areas with tough gun laws are cited as proof of the effectiveness of control, increasing youth homicide rates in the same areas are cited as proof of its futility.
Hold a "Youth Summit," inviting local, state, and federal officials to hear from the students on this issue. He argues that a guaranteed right to bear arms under any circumstances, including those that Public policy analysis gun control endanger public safety, would provide grounds for repeal of the amendment rather than a case for respecting it.
Try to get some students in each group who favor the approach and others who oppose it, at least based on the preliminary discussions. Proponents argue that these are largely state and local laws with limited impact, and that without them incident rates would be even higher.
Approximately million guns became available to the general public between andaccording to statistics compiled by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, but some of these are presumably no longer in existence or at least not in working order. Both sides use comparative data from other countries to bolster their arguments.
What about alternative policies? This "lethality," in suicide and accidents as well as homicide, is the imperative from a public health perspective for regulating guns like other deadly substances. Some provide support for popularly held notions, while others might cause students to examine the motives as well as the content of some policy stances.
Gordon Witkin, "The Great Debate: The "Debate" Reducing the issue of gun control to "pros" and "cons" is probably the least desirable outcome of studying gun control, but it may be a very useful beginning.
Majorities also favor background checks for private and gun show sales, though the number of Republicans and GOP-leaning independents falls slightly to three in four on this potential policy. Department of Justice, July Others would argue that the role of law is not primarily to change behavior, but to reflect the behavioral norms that a society professes.
At a minimum, it seems useful to try to quantify the problem, if not its exact nature. Some of the most persuasive of the gun control opponents employ economic arguments, using rational choice theory to demonstrate the inability of regulation to stop the flow of guns into neighborhoods where crime is the dominant employer in local labor markets.
Those on the other side, fearing to give even an inch, wind up defending the extremes on pure principle. Public policy based on the wedge approach risks forfeiting practical achievement in favor of principles taken to an extreme.
Recognizing citizen participation as a key element in that legitimacy lends practicality to the teaching of civic virtue in order to reduce violence. But the rancorous, uncivil, and often unproductive nature of the debate-as it has been conducted in the real-life models of state legislatures, the national media, and the halls of Congress-is at odds with producing either good citizens or effective policy.
Stronger gun control laws will make it more difficult for citizens to protect themselves and their families. Students might also look at other problems with parallel conditions that might suggest solutions to the problem of gun violence.
Greg Abbott told CNN on Monday morning that the shooter "sought to get a license to carry a gun in the state of Texas, but the state denied him the ability to get one," stressing that it was still early in the investigation.
But it is not only understanding "the issues" related to violence that makes the social studies pivotal in the violence prevention movement.
Texas shooting a mental health problem What problems is it designed to address? Agreeing on a desirable end is the first step in making good public policy. Below are some of the most frequently heard arguments in the debates over handgun laws.
But they may also cover up important areas of middle ground.Gun Control Policies in the United States Debates about gun control often drift towards general arguments about whether guns make us safer or less safe, and gun control is equated with restricting gun ownership.
However, gun policies could enhance public safety in the United States. 3. Gun Control: The Debate and Public Policy by Christine Watkins Violence is frequently the lead story on the evening news.
Crime and its prevention often figure prominently in. ANALYSIS OF STATES GUN CONTROL RESTRICTIONS Xiaofeng Cheng A thesis submitted to the Faculty of the University of South Florida in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Analysis of Gun Control Policy Effects 18 The Overview of Rational Choice Theory Oct 02, · It's no secret that Washington has long been divided on new gun control laws.
But Americans themselves might not be so divided (at least, on a few things) after all. High-profile mass shootings in the United States in recent years have rekindled the gun control debate and U.S.
Gun Policy: Global Comparisons. The incident sparked a public campaign known. Find Gun Policy Facts. Armed violence prevention, gun control laws and the small arms trade: mint-body.com provides evidence-based, public health-oriented information on armed violence, small arms policy and firearm-related injury prevention around the world.Download