Richard larson the research paper in the writing course

Academic and professional writing is a complex, recursive process that includes both research, or data-gathering, and reading from start to finish. This article, published in Research Strategies Brent disagrees, pointing out that the reading, writing, and research processes should be inseparable.

To better understand the history of slavery and abolition in New York State, the students examine slave bills of sale and runaway slave ads from the late 18th and early 19th centuries.

Bringing students into the archives opens a new avenue for undergraduate research. Journals that are no longer published or that have been combined with another title. To give students a greater stake in their writing, I purposefully choose documents that my students can connect to on a local and personal level.

Writers develop a sense of rhetorical purpose as the process unfolds, not strictly before the acts of researching and writing For example, if the current year is and a journal has a 5 year moving wall, articles from the year are available. For example, examining arrest records related to a Civil Rights protest provides many clues but few clear-cut answers to what happened that day.

As student researchers use retrieval tools to help them find where these "conversations" are going on, they choose how and where to tap into the network of scholarly communication.

Ablex,pp. Although instructors and librarians agree on the importance of being able to "do good research," they diverge in their definition of what that is—largely because they have subtly different ends in mind. This seemingly efficient strategy yields poor results. I think they should be held accountable for their opinions and should be required to say, from evidence, why they believe what they assert.

One of the goals of the learning community is to awaken a curiosity about local history and the causes of racial discrimination and inequality.

Both are often outgrowths of laboratory or field experiments, formal or intuitive observations, or extensive reading.

Thus research involving secondary sources is seen as only preliminary to, not part of, the process of creating new meaning Students can also be encouraged to interpret the nature of an article or book chapter on the basis of the journal or book in which it appears.

Schmersahl, "Teaching Library Research: Suggest that they formulate their purposes before they call a halt to library work so that they can seek the evidence best suited to their purposes.


Margaret Kantz reminds us that the purpose of such information is to support claims made by the text. Kohl and Lizabeth A. Being able to retrieve information does not necessarily make for good research.

However, it is necessary to have a sound knowledge of a discipline tempered with some imagination to have sufficient insight to recognize underlying questions within a subject or to see connections between seemingly unrelated events By examining a small number of primary sources, my students develop close observation and reading skills that lead to more focused and nuanced arguments.

And more important, it will help students to situate their research findings in a text of their own that uses evidence in a more sophisticated and successful way. Journals with no new volumes being added to the archive.

Because students are engaged by the research topic, they are motivated to puzzle over the meanings of a document, to pose questions, and to find the answers by reading deeply and carefully in secondary literature.

College English is the professional journal for the college scholar-teacher. Librarians generally focus on the significance of information retrieval and evaluation.


I detected no searching, analyzing, evaluating, synthesizing, selecting, rejecting, etc. A one-page article is more likely to report on a phenomenon, while a twelve-page article is more likely to analyze it.

Teaching library research as information retrieval through access tools valorizes information retrieval as the purpose of research--a misconception that puzzles students and frustrates teachers.

In rare instances, a publisher has elected to have a "zero" moving wall, so their current issues are available in JSTOR shortly after publication.Richard Larson On Research Papers richard-larson-on-research-papers. The same volume includes Richard Larson’s still-cited “The ‘Research Paper’ in the Writing Course: A Non-Form of Writing,” which argued for assignments more closely resembling research-based genres outside the classroom.

Jan 25,  · Larson, Richard L. “The ‘Research Paper’ in the Writing Course.” In The Writing Teachers Sourcebook. The ambiguous, often-assigned ‘research paper’ has three fundamental problems for writing teachers and composition.

Larson, Richard L. “The ‘Research Paper’ in the Writing Course.” In The Writing Teachers Sourcebook. The ambiguous, often-assigned ‘research paper’ has three fundamental problems for writing teachers and composition. Teaching the Rhetorical Dimensions of Research Composition teachers, often saddled with teaching generic research writing skills in a basic composition course,(7) find that one of the most difficult aspects of this task is to define research writing in a meaningful way for students.

(10)Richard L. Larson, "The 'Research Paper' in the. A great deal of criticism has been heaped on the first-year composition research paper going back, at least, to Richard Larson’s objections to it in as a “non-form of writing.” 1 These assignments often lead first year students to choose uncontroversial topics, to fail to make a compelling argument, to include unexamined presuppositions, and to insert .

Richard larson the research paper in the writing course
Rated 5/5 based on 39 review